论文标题

通过卡塞诺特分析解开儿童福利中无形的工作实践,约束和潜在权力关系

Unpacking Invisible Work Practices, Constraints, and Latent Power Relationships in Child Welfare through Casenote Analysis

论文作者

Saxena, Devansh, Moon, Erina Seh-Young, Shehata, Dahlia, Guha, Shion

论文摘要

案例工作者接受了培训,可以撰写有关儿童福利(CW)家庭的详细叙述,该叙述为协作高风险决策提供了信息。与其他行政数据不同,这些叙述为工人与家人的互动提供了更可靠的信息来源,并强调了系统因素在决策中的作用。 Sigchi的研究人员强调,有必要在街道级别上了解人类酌处权,以便能够为公共部门设计以人为本的算法。在这项研究中,我们在美国中西部的儿童福利机构对Casenotes进行了计算文本分析,并突出了对算法设计的直接影响的无形街道级别可酌情工作和潜在功率结构的模式。 Casenotes为决策者和CW领导提供了独特的镜头,以了解地面案例工作者的经验。这项研究的结果是,我们重点介绍了如何通过以工人为中心的设计开发的社会技术系统来支持街道级别的酌处工作。这项研究提供了对Casenotes的首次计算检查,并将其介绍给Sigchi社区,作为研究复杂社会技术系统的关键数据源。

Caseworkers are trained to write detailed narratives about families in Child-Welfare (CW) which informs collaborative high-stakes decision-making. Unlike other administrative data, these narratives offer a more credible source of information with respect to workers' interactions with families as well as underscore the role of systemic factors in decision-making. SIGCHI researchers have emphasized the need to understand human discretion at the street-level to be able to design human-centered algorithms for the public sector. In this study, we conducted computational text analysis of casenotes at a child-welfare agency in the midwestern United States and highlight patterns of invisible street-level discretionary work and latent power structures that have direct implications for algorithm design. Casenotes offer a unique lens for policymakers and CW leadership towards understanding the experiences of on-the-ground caseworkers. As a result of this study, we highlight how street-level discretionary work needs to be supported by sociotechnical systems developed through worker-centered design. This study offers the first computational inspection of casenotes and introduces them to the SIGCHI community as a critical data source for studying complex sociotechnical systems.

扫码加入交流群

加入微信交流群

微信交流群二维码

扫码加入学术交流群,获取更多资源