论文标题

不是另一个学校资源图:满足服务不足的家庭的信息需求需要信任关系和个性化护理

Not Another School Resource Map: Meeting Underserved Families' Information Needs Requires Trusting Relationships and Personalized Care

论文作者

Robertson, Samantha, Nguyen, Tonya, Salehi, Niloufar

论文摘要

美国各地的公立学区已经实施了学校选择系统,这些系统有可能改善服务不足的学生获得教育机会。但是,研究表明,学习和申请学校可能非常耗时且昂贵,这使得这些系统难以在实践中更公平地访问资源。先前工作中浮出水面的一个共同因素是无法获得有关学校和入学过程的信息。作为回应,政府和非营利组织已经投资了通过详细的在线仪表板向父母提供有关学校的更多信息。但是,我们对哪些信息实际上对历史上边缘化和服务不足的家庭有用。我们对10个低收入家庭和有色人种家庭进行了访谈,以了解他们面临的在线学校选择和入学系统所面临的挑战。我们通过对从学校校长到非营利性员工的各种角色来支持家庭的人进行了四次访谈(“父母倡导者”),对这些数据进行了补充。我们的发现突出了个性化支持和信任关系的价值,以提供相关和有用的信息。我们将其与在线信息资源和仪表板进行对比,这些资源和仪表板往往是非个人的,针对广泛的受众,并对父母在学校中应寻找的东西做出了强有力的假设,而对家庭的变化情况敏感。我们主张在公立学校入学中采用基于资产的设计方法来提供信息支持,该方法将询问我们如何支持社区成员已经提供的本地一对一支持。

Public school districts across the United States have implemented school choice systems that have the potential to improve underserved students' access to educational opportunities. However, research has shown that learning about and applying for schools can be extremely time-consuming and expensive, making it difficult for these systems to create more equitable access to resources in practice. A common factor surfaced in prior work is unequal access to information about the schools and enrollment process. In response, governments and non-profits have invested in providing more information about schools to parents, for instance, through detailed online dashboards. However, we know little about what information is actually useful for historically marginalized and underserved families. We conducted interviews with 10 low-income families and families of color to learn about the challenges they faced navigating an online school choice and enrollment system. We complement this data with four interviews with people who have supported families through the enrollment process in a wide range of roles, from school principal to non-profit staff ("parent advocates"). Our findings highlight the value of personalized support and trusting relationships to delivering relevant and helpful information. We contrast this against online information resources and dashboards, which tend to be impersonal, target a broad audience, and make strong assumptions about what parents should look for in a school without sensitivity to families' varying circumstances. We advocate for an assets-based design approach to information support in public school enrollment, which would ask how we can support the local, one-on-one support that community members already provide.

扫码加入交流群

加入微信交流群

微信交流群二维码

扫码加入学术交流群,获取更多资源