论文标题

在教育视频中衡量性别偏见:YouTube上的案例研究

Measuring Gender Bias in Educational Videos: A Case Study on YouTube

论文作者

Gezici, Gizem, Saygin, Yucel

论文摘要

学生越来越多地使用在线材料来学习新学科或在教育机构中补充他们的学习过程。在正规教育的背景下,已经提出了有关性别偏见的问题,并提出了一些减轻他们的措施。但是,在可能以不同形式出现的性别偏见和陈规定型观念方面,在广泛使用的搜索平台中搜索偏见的背景下,在线教育材料尚待研究。作为衡量在线平台中可能的性别偏见的第一步,我们已经根据其叙述者的性别研究了YouTube教育视频。我们采取了对排名搜索结果的偏见措施,以评估YouTube返回的教育视频,以响应与STEM(科学,技术,工程和数学)和非STUM教育领域有关的查询。性别是社会科学本身的研究领域,这超出了这项工作的范围。在这方面,为了注释教学视频的叙述者的性别,我们仅将性别分类用于男性和女性。然后,为了分析感知到的性别偏见,我们利用了受搜索平台启发的偏差措施,并进一步将等级信息纳入我们的分析中。我们的初步结果表明,在返回的YouTube教育视频中,男性性别存在很大的偏见,当我们比较STEM和非STEM查询时,偏见的程度也有所不同。最后,有强有力的证据表明等级信息可能会影响结果。

Students are increasingly using online materials to learn new subjects or to supplement their learning process in educational institutions. Issues regarding gender bias have been raised in the context of formal education and some measures have been proposed to mitigate them. However, online educational materials in terms of possible gender bias and stereotypes which may appear in different forms are yet to be investigated in the context of search bias in a widely-used search platform. As a first step towards measuring possible gender bias in online platforms, we have investigated YouTube educational videos in terms of the perceived gender of their narrators. We adopted bias measures for ranked search results to evaluate educational videos returned by YouTube in response to queries related to STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics) and NON-STEM fields of education. Gender is a research area by itself in social sciences which is beyond the scope of this work. In this respect, for annotating the perceived gender of the narrator of an instructional video we used only a crude classification of gender into Male, and Female. Then, for analysing perceived gender bias we utilised bias measures that have been inspired by search platforms and further incorporated rank information into our analysis. Our preliminary results demonstrate that there is a significant bias towards the male gender on the returned YouTube educational videos, and the degree of bias varies when we compare STEM and NON-STEM queries. Finally, there is a strong evidence that rank information might affect the results.

扫码加入交流群

加入微信交流群

微信交流群二维码

扫码加入学术交流群,获取更多资源